Eagle Eye (indyeagleeye) wrote,
Eagle Eye

John Rentoul: Cameron's biggest U-turn

How much do the "progressive" Conservatives care about poverty? Reading Tim Bale's book about which I enthused on Sunday, and which can be pre-ordered here, reminded me of one of David Cameron's early U-turns. (His most recent was to insist on all-women shortlists and then to back off.)

Do you remember when in February 2006 Cameron announced a statement of the party's aims and values, called Built to Last? No? Well, it was no Clause IV moment. But the document was discussed, amended and then put to the vote of the whole membership in September 2006, and approved by 93 per cent (on a less-than-enthusiastic 27 per cent turnout).

Bale comments on some changes between the first and last drafts of the document, but misses what I think is the most important one.

Spot the difference.

Built to Last
(pdf): first draft:

"The right test for our policies is how they help the most disadvantaged in society, not the rich."

(pdf) voted on by members:

"The test of a strong and just society is how it looks after the least advantaged – but this duty is not reserved for the state alone."

They keep wriggling on the promise to cut inheritance tax for a few of the richest people in the country. When I reminded a member of Team Cameron last year of the first statement, he said that it may be the test, "but that doesn't mean we have to pass it".


Photo: John Taylor.
Tags: david cameron, equality

  • Ben Chu: A word please, Prime Minister

    "How about that apology?" The UK is now growing faster than France and Germany. The latest Office for National Statistics report…

  • John Rentoul: David Cameron uncut

    Just one more thing to note from our Independent on Sunday interview with David Cameron (right: photograph by Justin Sutcliffe), who is likely to…

  • John Rentoul: My JK Rowling Moment

    Mind you, I nearly had a JK Rowling Moment as I was writing my article saying I preferred David Cameron as prime minister to Gordon Brown. She…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded